Helping an Older Couple Led Me to a Generational Work Cycle

The other day I was out walking and brainstorming when I came across an older couple trying to unload wood paneling from their truck and carry it into their house. It was almost comedic. The husband would grab a plank and go inside, and the whole time he was gone his wife would struggle to get the next piece out of the truck, until he came back and took it from her.

By the time I walked past their house, the man was sweating and clearly exhausted, so I offered to help. A few minutes later the truck was empty and all the wood was upstairs, ready for them to eventually lay in the attic. They thanked me over and over. In my head it was no big deal. It had cost me about ten minutes, I wasn’t tired, and I wasn’t doing anything else anyway.

I kept walking for another ten minutes or so before a truck pulled up next to me and the window rolled down. I was caught off guard because I was deep in thought, but I quickly realized it was the same couple. They had driven out just to thank me one more time.

That stuck with me. It showed me how much that tiny act meant to them, and it sent me on a three-hour thinking walk that ended with two conclusions.

Idea one: people need the opportunity to do good

I’ll start with the quick one. People have to be given the opportunity to do good.

I thought back to my time in the corporate world, when I had so little free time that I might not have stopped to help. If I had been walking the dog, I may have seen the couple, kept my head down, and gone home to rest and recover. This time I had the time and the energy, and I felt good, so I was able to help.

That makes me think our work/life balance may be making people less willing to be kind and generous with their time. If we want friendlier communities, working less may help. People can only help when they have something left to give.

Idea two: a cycle where the young work for the old

The bigger idea is a cyclical concept of society that is fun to think through, even though it doesn’t work at full scale.

It was so easy for me to make an older couple happy that I started to wonder whether it should be the obligation of younger people to work for older people. Here is how it would go:

  1. Older people pay younger people for their help.
  2. The younger people save that money throughout their lives.
  3. When they are older, they use those savings to pay the next generation to help them.

It felt like a wholesome cycle. It would leave the people with the greatest needs holding the most money, and it would give them company as they pass down their wisdom.

In practice, 20-year-olds do have real needs. But most of what they spend money on are wants, and many of those are luxuries. Maybe luxuries should be reserved for people who have already done their service, and the younger generation could work to save up for those later-in-life luxuries.

Where the idea breaks down

I don’t expect this to work as a real system, and a few problems are obvious:

  • Not every older person has money. A cycle built on savings leaves out people who never had the chance to save.
  • Trust and safety. Strangers working inside people’s homes needs some way of vetting and protecting both sides.
  • Choice. Many young people would not want their income and spending shaped this way, and forcing it would remove the kindness that made the original moment work.

What would still need research and development

An idea like this can’t go straight from a walk to a policy. It would need real research and development first, and I don’t have the answers to these questions:

  • Societal growth. If young people spend their early years doing paid work for older people, what happens to the things that usually drive growth, such as starting businesses, learning new skills and building careers? The cycle might strengthen communities while slowing the economy, or it might not. That needs to be measured and not assumed.
  • Public servants. Programs like this could grow out of public service. Could public servants, civic service programs or community organizations match young workers with older people, handle vetting and payment, and keep the arrangement fair? It’s also worth asking whether this would replace existing services or support them.
  • Money and retirement. The cycle would sit alongside pensions, Social Security, taxes and savings. How the pieces fit, and who pays when the numbers don’t line up, is not something a thought experiment can settle.
  • Small pilots first. The sensible way to learn more is to test a small version in one community and see what happens to the people on both sides.

Still, the part I keep coming back to is the small one. Ten minutes of help made two people’s day, and it only happened because I had the time. A society that leaves people more room to notice and help may end up kinder than one that only rewards them for being busy.

CommunityIdeasPsychologySociologyWork Life Balance